Children’s Books – ‘The Graveyard Book,’ Written by Neil Gaiman. Illustrated by Dave McKean – Review – NYTimes.com
Filed under Neil Gaiman, New York Times Review, Newbery
what a great review, Monica! Congratulations!
Thank you very much, Monica. Not sure what else to say. Just thank you.
I have a book report to do and I read your book for it. I need to type a apge for it ,and I dont know what the theme would be. Can you help me out?
I began reading it without looking at the byline and thought “hey this sounds like….is it…..IT IS.”
I’m not sure what I’m more psyched about, the review in the NYT or that it’s YOUR review!
Nice job! Congratulations. I notice your review was read by an award winning author!
Great review! I always enjoy hearing about the interactions between your class and the literature you present to them. I can’t wait to read the book!
Congratulations, Monica! What a thrill and what a great review!
A lovely review which makes me want to read it, and I’m not even a Gaiman fan!
Great review, and congrats on appearing in the Times! I have to – not disagree, since I agree completely – but pipe up and say that I think The Graveyard Book is equally “for” grownups as for children. The novel’s conclusion seems to me to have real resonance for both children and adults (and maybe especially for teenagers?) – the themes of growing up, moving on, facing the big world: those really are universals, no?
I’m glad your 4th graders were fine with the first chapter; *I* found it absolutely blood-curdling. I shouldn’t be surprised that nine-year-olds are tougher than I am.
Not only a tour de force of reviewing – a small number of words, packed with meaning, analysis, and elegance – but in the NYTimes and appreciated by the author. Brava, brava, brava!
An elegant, engaging written review of an elegant, engaging book! Unsurprising, considering the source! And in response to Kerry, I just want to point out that Monica said specifically in the article that it “will entertain people of all ages.” I think her point – a hugely important one considering the post-Silvey discussions about the Newbery – is that it IS for children and NOT just something that pleases adults, or the Newbery committee, or both. I didn’t get any sense that Monica didn’t think it was for grownups or teenagers – and here I completely agree with Kerry, I could see reading this to or with kids of all ages, and I think it’d be particularly great for reluctant readers in middle school and high school – but rather that she was directing addressing the recent worries about whether this recipient of the Newbery as the most “distinguished contribution to children’s literature,” is, in fact, interesting to children. Which is is, tra-la!
Excellent review Monica-and in the NYT!! I plan on sharing your review with my students as I shared the project your students did. I’ve enjoyed “knowing” you long distance for quite some time now – you’ve been a role model for many in- and pre-service teachers.
Congratulations, my friend! It is, as GraceAnne says, a remarkable review given the brief and the brevity. You said everything that needed to be said and more. Cheers from down under.
Thanks, everyone! As you can imagine, it was pure pleasure for me to review this book. My first for the Times, but hopefully not my last.
Fantastic review — made me even more eager to read this!
Congrats, Monica! I hope this is the first review of many more to come!
An excellent review. I loved Coraline and am looking forward to reading this one. And thanks for posting the link on child_lit that led me here!
Wonderful review, Monica, and congrats on writing it, too. It is fun following your fandom of this book!
Pingback: Reviews at Edinger House
Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:
You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. ( Log Out / Change )
You are commenting using your Twitter account. ( Log Out / Change )
You are commenting using your Facebook account. ( Log Out / Change )
You are commenting using your Google+ account. ( Log Out / Change )
Connecting to %s
Notify me of new comments via email.
Notify me of new posts via email.
Join 5,098 other followers