Everyone’s a Little Bit Book Bannerish

It is Banned Book Week, when we draw attention to books that are kept out of readers’ hands, acts of censorship, and efforts to ban books across the United States.  These sadly often involve individuals successfully seeing to it that a book is not used in a school, taken off a library shelf, or otherwise kept away from its readers.  Frequently the challenges come about because of religious reasons, differences in ideas about parenting, apprehension about the mention of anything sexual, violence, and more.  I have great admiration for all the writers, teachers, librarians, and book lovers who work fiercely and unceasingly to get the word out about this.

But it also has me wonder — what about the books I keep away from my students?  The books that make me uncomfortable?  Sure, some of them are old and will wither away, but there are others too.   For years one of my favorite books to read aloud was Gary Paulsen’s Harris and Me — until the year I had a Japanese child in the class.  Set on an isolated farm during World War II, the young narrator is drawn into one escapade after another by his wild cousin, Harris.  That year  I got to the point when Harris wanted to play war and called the pigs “Commie Japs” and  I stopped, suddenly hyperaware of how that must sound to my Japanese student.  I then attempted a long explanation about the phrase. How Harris had the vaguest sense of the Japanese and only that they were the enemy and so forth and so on.  My Japanese student looked puzzled as did the rest of the class.  I went on and read the rest of the book — leaving out every subsequent mention of those Commie Japs.  And that awakening caused me to never read the book aloud again. So perhaps I’m a book banner of sorts.

And how about last year’s discussion around the Kickapoo Princess in Richard Peck’s A Season of Gifts?  While some may have kept the book on their library shelves I have to wonder if others backed off from it in other ways, ways more along the lines of my doing so with Harris and Me.  Perhaps this isn’t really book banning, but then what is it exactly?

I think it is always a good idea as we rail against small mindedness to consider if we ourselves are doing some of that ourselves.  When I came of age in the 70s we were frequently urged to recognize our own racism and later reflect on white privilege.  Sort of like that Avenue Q song —“Everyone’s a Little Bit Racist.”  For me book banning is probably on a continuum — there is the quiet sort of not-using-a-book-as-it-has-stuff-that-makes-me-uncomfortable at one end and the egregious sort that makes headlines at the other end.  And so I think that during this important week that as we speak up against censorship we should also reflect on whether we do any of it ourselves.

Also at the Huffington Post.



Filed under Huffington Post

5 responses to “Everyone’s a Little Bit Book Bannerish

  1. mwt

    Monica, I believe in the freedom to read. I also believe in the freedom to not read. I think we should infringe on those freedoms only when we have compelling reasons. So, I think it’s fine that you callously force your fourth graders to read every day. : ) But I would be less comfortable if you regularly told them exactly which books they must read. For me there is a line, rarely discussed, between having a book available on a shelf, and forcing children to read it or listen to it. So, I’d be okay with a parent who asked you not to read Little House on the Prairie in the classroom, but less happy with one that demanded you take it out of your classroom.


  2. Yes, that line is not discussed much at all. I still have Harris and Me in the classroom — I’m just not reading it aloud anymore.


  3. I agree with mwt’s comment — the freedom to read comes hand in hand with the freedom to choose NOT to read something. It is the freedom to choose one or the other that is the key. And not to have someone else — someone outside of me and my family — try to decide for us. I had a similar reaction when reading Little House out loud to my young daughter — and went off on a long (too long) explanation of why Ma talked about the native americans “in that way.” In the end, I was glad to have a way to talk about racism with my kid — and I think she’s better off to have had that conversation with me about a book before encountering it in real life.
    I blogged about this recently on http://www.carpekeyboard.blogspot.com.

    Nice post!


  4. Pingback: Rasco From RIF » Banned Books Week 2010

  5. Pingback: Top 5 Depressing Children’s Books « Reads for Keeps

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.