My Impressions of Hugo

Last year I began my year-long study of Charlie Chaplin by reading aloud to my fourth grade class Brian Selznick’s The Invention of Hugo Cabret. I  wasn’t sure what it would be like reading aloud a story that depended on so many pages of pure art, but it worked out beautifully.

I wondered even more how Martin Scorsese would manage to pay honor to such a special sort of storytelling and last night I got my answer. Scholastic most kindly invited me to a screening and I can assure you:  Hugo is absolutely lovely. Fans of the book (like me) have nothing to be worried about — Scorsese and the others involved have embraced the theme, the feeling, the delight of the book in a cinematic way that compliments the story in the most wonderful way.

There is much to consider about the movie, say the way it celebrates film, early film, those works of George Méliès in particular.  But it also beautifully brings out themes of connecting as people, of fixing (clockworks, toys, automatons, people), as well as the pleasures of a certain time and place.  In fact, for all the remarkable imagery (3D at times), there is something quite old-fashioned about the movie. I loved the way Scorsese managed to translate some of the dramatic and exciting series of drawings in the book into film; each is its own thing, but both provide similar emotional drama.  What struck me as from an older time cinematically (say the time the movie is set — 1930s) were the quieter moments — especially the lovely ones showing loving relationships: new and old — the more I think about it, the more I love those as I think they ask viewers, especially children, so used to speedy story telling, to slow down a bit, here and there.

An absolute delight.  A beauty. Go.



Filed under Film

8 responses to “My Impressions of Hugo

  1. Thank you, we plan to go! Love your posts! And I wish I were in your class.


  2. Thank you for this… a group of us here (Vancouverites for Steampunk) in Vancouver are aiming to dress up in our steampunk best and catch the show this Friday! Exciting!


  3. Thanks for the review – I am excited to see it!!


  4. Maia

    Finally, a movie I can’t wait to see… thanks for the review!


  5. Judy Weymouth

    My husband and I saw the movie this afternoon . . . with two other people in an otherwise empty theater. Both of us were completely satisfied and delighted with the film. I hope there will be recognition at award time!


  6. Pingback: Monica Edinger: Martin Scorsese’s Hugo: A Delight for Kids and Grownups Alike

  7. I have not yet seen Hugo, but after your marvelous review of it, I know that I must go and see it! After all, you are the ultimate connoisseur of both movies and books alike.


  8. Sounds like this is definitely one to go see on the large screen! I heard Scorsese talk about it on The Daily Show, and he was absolutely exuberant, like a young boy – his pleasure was so clear. Glad to know he did a good job.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.