Jews, Antisemitism, and White Privilege Today

Recently I attended a superb workshop at the National Museum of African American History and Culture called “Let’s Talk: Teaching Race in the Classroom.” At one point we were asked to join one of two affinity groups: POC and White. As I was heading to the room for the White group, the leader said loudly something along the lines of: “And Jews are not POCs. Judaism is a religion not a race.” This made me very uncomfortable because, while I identify as Jewish due to my ancestry, I have never had any connection to the religion, and I’ve never considered myself anything other than White. It hadn’t occurred to me that anyone in the room who identified as Jewish and had already spoken from the White perspective would think differently.

A POC friend also in attendance said afterwards, when I complained to her, that she had noticed that several Whites had not moved, perhaps provoking the organizer to make that statement. She also told me that one of the lead educators had told her that until recently Jews were identified as a separate race in the DC area and perhaps that was the genesis of the comment. I didn’t buy that as I was well aware of this being the case in many places around the country and the world, but didn’t see it as how we should think of ourselves. In fact, I feel strongly that far from identifying as a race separate from other Whites, we Jews need to acknowledge and own our White privilege. (See my post from a couple of years ago, “The Holocaust and White Privilege, for my thoughts on this.)

However, the events in Charlottesville and Eric K. Ward’s superb “Skin in the Game: How Antisemitism Animates White Nationalism” have me thinking hard about the reality of anti-semitism today in our country. Now a senior fellow at the Southern Poverty Center, Ward has a long and distinguished career in civil rights as well as in leading campaigns against hate groups such as those who organized and participated in the Charlottesville event.

Ward’s essay is long, but very accessible to read, and so important for all to know more. Here’s a taste:

Over years of speaking about White nationalism in the 1990s and early 2000s in the Northwest and then the Midwest and South, I found that audiences—whether white or of color, at synagogues or churches, universities or police trainings—generally had a relationship to white nationalism that, at least in one basic sense, was like my own. They knew the scope and seriousness of the movement from personal experience, and—if they didn’t take this for granted to begin with—they were not shocked to discover its antisemitic emphasis. The resistance I have encountered when I address antisemitism has primarily come since I moved to the Northeast seven years ago, and from the most established progressive antiracist leaders, organizations, coalitions, and foundations around the country. It is here that a well-meaning but counterproductive thicket of discourse has grown up insisting that Jews—of Ashkenazi descent, at least—are uncontestably White, and that to challenge this is to deny the workings of White privilege. In other words, when I’m asked, “Where is the antisemitism?,” what I am often really being asked is, “Why should we be talking about antisemitism?”

I still own my White Privilege, but I do also think all of us who are concerned — whatever our identity —need to be aware and informed as to the centrality anti-semitism plays in the mindset of groups like those who were at Charlottesville.  These are dangerous times.



Filed under Other

5 responses to “Jews, Antisemitism, and White Privilege Today

  1. Thanks for this. I am worried about my nephew, who is a law student at the University of Virginia and is Jewish. I don’t understand how Trump can have Jewish grandchildren and not condemn these Nazis. Of course, he does not have a great grasp of history.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. dheiligman

    Yes, we cannot ignore the anti-Semitic origins of these bigoted groups. I think Nathan Englander’s op-ed in the NY Times today is also worth reading, and speaks to this point. I have always felt an affinity with POC from growing up Jewish in a predominantly non-Jewish town. Even though the Jewish community was strong, we were a minority. So to this day I feel like a minority, pretty much wherever I am. BUT. There is a huge difference, of course. You cannot tell by looking at me “what” I am. So I can walk down the street anywhere and not fear that I will be murdered because of my skin color. And yet, inside…. I feel like there is more that unites us than divides us. I don’t know which group I would have felt most at home in at your workshop.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Melanie

    Shocking but not surprising that not a single person of any race or religion stood up at your event to protest the Smithsonian group leader’s foolish and anti-Semitic characterization of Jewishness being a religion and not a transnational people. Did he really see Jewishness the same as he would see Presbyterian Christianity or Zoroastrianism? Does anyone? If they do, they need multicultural education.

    Over history, our Jewish friends have been persecuted both for what they believe religiously and who they are via bloodlines. Half the world’s Jews are non-white; they feel people kinship to white Jews and vice-versa, and probably have more in common with them than they do with non-Jews of their same nationalities if their Judaism includes religious practice, as it does in most of the world. The SJW movement is happy to have Jewish support, but will only support back a certain vision of Judaism that includes leftist ideology; a Judaism and Jewishness that cares more about matzah ball soup, finding lox, and warm stories from a grandparent, than fearing the God of their patriarchs and matriarchs, and learning and living by all that God taught, as Christians fear God and learning and living by the life and death of Jesus Christ.

    P.S. You can’t tell who most GLBTQIA people are by looking at them, nor many disabled people with hidden illnesses. They’re still minorities.


    • Oh, I spoke up immediately and the leader said, I was right that it wasn’t a religion, but a culture and she herself was culturally Jewish. I left it at that given that we were off to the affinity groups and had no further opportunity to address it. (The consultant was only there for the day.)

      Liked by 1 person

  4. annettepimentel

    The United States has a long, twisted, bizarre history of assigning races. I’ve been researching the history of the US Census and have been completely floored by what is and isn’t considered a race and how that has changed over time. As recently as1940 “Hindu” was one of the race options on the US Census.

    Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.