The Two Umas’ “Out of the Way! Out of the Way!”

When Uma Krishnaswami asked me if I would like to participate in a blog tour I was intrigued. I’ve never done one, but the featured book (illustrated by another Uma, Uma Krishnaswamy) looked charming online and was being brought out by the admirable Indian publisher Tulika Books.  So I said yes.

I’m glad I did.  A clever cumulative tale for very young children, the book is a pleasure to read and view.  Having never been to India I can’t weigh in on authenticity, but it comes across as very real. Set in India, created and published in India, it offers an insider’s view of India, understandably quite different from the one you get, no matter how well-intended and well-researched,  created and published by outsiders.  Those looking for books about other cultures and places for young kids should definitely snap this one up.

Wanting a more youthful perspective I read the book to some of my book blogging 6th graders and invited them to write their own blog posts.

  • Wrote KM, “It’s set in India, which is one reason I liked it so much. I go to India every summer to see family, and so I also have a general idea of the setting and stuff.”  Read her whole post here.
  • LW gave it a 9.5 out of 10 and thought that it is, “….  kind of like The Giving Tree, except that in The Giving Tree the boy was very selfish and cruel to the tree, but in this book the boy really loved the tree and protected it from all of the dangers of a growing city.” Read her whole post here.
  • TB notes that the book has a, “… wonderful collection of similes, India and a child’s love for the environment.” LD notes that “… it has that Indian tradition, which includes the modern part of India.” Read their whole post here.
  • In her post, RC urges you to move out of the way for this book.

So there’s our take on this pretty book.  For some other perspectives do visit the rest of the tour stops this week:

Monday June 21:
Educating Alice (Monica Edinger)
Saffron Tree (artnavy)
Tuesday June 22:
Chicken Spaghetti (Pooja Makhijani)
Through the Tollbooth (Sarah Sullivan)
Wednesday June 23:
PaperTigers (Marjorie Coughlan)
Thursday June 24:
Brown Paper (Niranjana Iyer)
Plot Whisperer (Martha Alderson)
Friday June 25:
Notes from New England (Nandini Bajpai)
Saffron Tree (artnavy)

Saturday June 26:
Scribbly Katia (Katia Novet Saint-Lot)
Jacket Knack (Carol Brendler)
Sunday June 27:
The Drift Record (Julie Larios)



11 Comments

Filed under Picture Books

11 responses to “The Two Umas’ “Out of the Way! Out of the Way!”

  1. Very interesting what the children have to say…my little one discovers new elements in the illiustrations each time we read it

    Like

  2. I’ve really enjoyed reading your students’ reviews – what a great start to Out of the Way’s blog tour. I’m looking forward to hosting on Wednesday…

    Like

  3. Anu

    very interesting perspectives…… must get my son to read it soon and see what he comes up with!

    Like

  4. Pingback: Out of the Way for a Blog Tour!

  5. Great comments from the student bloggers. I loved the Giving Tree so that analogy really perked my interest. The cover is beautiful. Can’t wait to see the inside.

    Like

  6. Thank you so much for sharing what your students thought of the book. =)

    Like

  7. Such an interesting way to construct a post, with your students’ reviews forming the critique. I enjoyed this very much!

    Like

  8. What a wonderful way of introducing children to the world of writing! I’m sure they must have enjoyed reading the book and writing about it, and getting their opinions validated by none other than the creators of the book. My 9yr old daughter is going to love this!

    Like

  9. Pingback: A tree grows in Bangalore « Brown Paper

  10. Adele

    Hi Monica! It’s funny, I’ve read a post on it on Saffron Tree while looking for a children book on kolams :)
    Really interesting!
    Bye, Adele

    Like

  11. Pingback: Some (Many) Spring 2012 Books I Am Eager To See « educating alice

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s